Back in Business and/or Black: The Art of the Comeback Album

More like Bat Back Into Hell – am I right? Anyone?

A comeback album is defined – at least for the sake of this article – as an album released after an artist has been written off.  Common causes include releasing a series of mediocre albums, a break from music, or the death of a band member. It’s difficult to survive such circumstances – The Doors, for instance, released three official albums after Jim Morrison died, but none are held in high regard. Most Doors fans to this day consider LA Woman their final album, with many not even knowing about post-Morrison Doors.

These four artists, however, overcame difficult odds and came back strong.

 Elvis Presley

The write off: It feels wrong to say that Elvis was ever written off, seeing as how the man never sang a bad note in his life, but by the mid 60s he was almost irrelevant. The British Invasion changed the musical landscape and there wasn’t much room for ol’ timey rockabilly. Elvis was also busy making bad formulaic movies with bad (but well sung) formulaic soundtracks, with perhaps the nadir of both being the song “Yoga Is as Yoga Does” from the film Easy Come Easy Go. (I’m serious.) Elvis became upset with his career, and supermanager Colonel Tom Parker managed to wrangle a deal to get him back on TV and let him do his first live performances since the early 60s. The result was what is now referred to as the ’68 Comeback Special, and as the title suggests relaunched his career and made him cool in the public’s eye again. All that was left to do was to show that his comeback wasn’t a fluke.

The comeback: From Elvis in Memphis

The comeback.

In a sentence, Elvis went back to being Elvis. The versatility, the passion, the pure talent – it’s all there on this record. Blues, rock, country, gospel, pop – all sung like everyone knew Elvis could sing. It may be the most varied album Elvis ever recorded in terms of genre, but it’s all connected with the Memphis sound. Perhaps the most famous song off the album is “In The Ghetto,” but the album also features a solid cover of “Hey Jude” by The Beatles and some classic-style Elvis ballads such as “I’ll Hold You In My Heart (Till I Can Hold You In My Arms).” Many list this as one of his best albums, if not his best,  because of the sincerity in it – sincerity absent  for far too long.


The write off: Their lead singer died. A mere six months after the release of Highway to Hell – a massive success credited with putting them among the top hard rock acts in the world at the time – lead singer Bon Scott was found dead in a car after a night of heavy drinking. This was a serious blow – both creatively and emotionally – to the band. To this day Scott is one of the more recognizable vocalists in rock, so they knew it would be a tall order replacing him. After briefly considering quitting, they picked up vocalist Brian Johnson from the band Geordie and started recording a new album.

The comeback: Back in Black

The comeback.

Back in Black was a modest success, by which I mean it is the second highest selling album in music history. If someone were to ever ask what constitutes “hard rock,” point them in the direction of this album. Unapologetic, growling, drag-your-enemies-to-hell, party-all-night hard rock in all of its simple, four-chord glory. It will knock you out with its Australian thighs. It’s nearly impossible to single out one or two songs because almost every song off of this album has become famous. It makes excellent driving music, air guitar music, and superhero entrance music. (Fun fact: for many years, “Hells Bells” was the entrance music for the New Jersey Devils hockey team, complete with the most awesome intro video this side of the 90s Chicago Bulls.)

 Southside Johnny & The Asbury Jukes

The write off: Southside Johnny has always been an underrated artist who suffered bad luck with the music industry, though if you’ve ever seen Home Alone or remember the sitcom Dave’s World, you’ve heard him. His first three albums – I Don’t Want to Go Home, This Time It’s For Real, and Hearts of Stone – did pretty well, and Hearts of Stone has been described as “the best album Bruce Springsteen never recorded.” The band was a staple of the Jersey Shore sound at its time, and still maintains a following. Due the aforementioned bad luck – in addition to being overshadowed by Springsteen – Southside never had much of a chance to get big. The band underwent many changes during the mid 80s and changed labels almost every album, but stopped acting as a unit under the “Asbury Jukes” title around 1983. In 1991, he Got The Band Back Together and put out his first studio album in years.

The comeback: Better Days

The comeback.

Better Days has a strong case for Most Jersey-charged Album Ever Released. On “It’s Been A Long Time,” Southside share lead vocals with Bruce Springsteen and Steve Van Zandt. “I’ve Been Working Too Hard” is a duet with Jon Bon Jovi.  Both songs are now concert staples. One reviewer even stated that it was “a comeback album that by all rights shouldn’t be this good.” The album also features Jersey Shore staples Max Weinberg, Garry Tallent, Steve Van Zandt, and Richie “La Bamba” Rosenberg on it, with a cameo by Flo & Eddie just for good measure. All of this adds up to make a solid album by any standards. Though Southside still hasn’t received the critical and commercial attention he deserves, this put him back in the business. He’s still a favorite in Europe and on the Jersey Shore – he performs on the Stone Pony summer stage each Fourth of July weekend to a full crowd. (Fun fact: the song “Better Days” was my theme song during my time as a college radio show host.)

Meat Loaf:

The write off: After the worldwide phenomenon that was Bat out of Hell, extensive touring began to take its toll on Meat Loaf. He became a drug addict, experienced nervous breakdowns, and for a period of time he straight up lost his singing voice. In 1981 he released a solid effort in Dead Ringer. He then entered into a legal dispute with his longtime songwriter Jim Steinman and over the course of the 80s released a series of forgettable (and that’s being generous) albums mostly to keep himself out of bankruptcy. During this time he improved his skills while touring and eventually reconciled with Steinman.

The comeback: Bat Out of Hell II: Back Into Hell

The comeback

If Bat Out of Hell is a teenager, Bat Out of Hell II is that same teenager as a cynical adult. While not as strong an album as the first Bat Out of Hell, Bat II was a stronger return to form for Meat Loaf than anyone predicted. Full of long operatic songs with long operatic titles that play on popular phrases, Bat II is the sequel Bat I deserved. Between long songs about a tragic youth (“Objects In the Rearview Mirror May Appear Closer Than They Are”) and a declaration that he would do anything for love (but he won’t do that), it brought back the bombastic themes and sound for which Meat Loaf became famous. His voice was allowed to soar, and his production was top notch.

The success of this album led to Meat Loaf to a performance of the national anthem at the 1994 MLB All-Star Game, credible film and TV roles, and eventually a spot on Celebrity Apprentice where he got into a fight with Gary Busey. (I’m still serious.)


That’s my list of best comeback albums. Do you have any favorites? Let us know in the comments below!

Post By David Lebovitz (48 Posts)

Pronounced Lee-BO-its. Basically a Rick Moranis character without the glasses. Imaginary late night talk show host. Has a degree in something called "communications."


One thought on “Back in Business and/or Black: The Art of the Comeback Album

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.